13 Comments
User's avatar
LeeAnn Pickrell's avatar

As an editor of an academic journal, I can’t tell you how much I appreciate authors who follow the guidelines. So much of my time is often spent correcting the formatting.

Expand full comment
Kathryn Anna Marshall's avatar

I can believe it! I've always followed the guidelines (I like things just so) but I've been privy to several discussions where the overriding feeling is that it's just fussiness. I think people find the whole process quite intimidating (not to mention how scary it can feel sending work off) so they don't stop to see the person and the reason behind the rules.

Expand full comment
Beth Brooke's avatar

Enjoyed this, thanks!

Expand full comment
Kathryn Anna Marshall's avatar

Thank you! I regard you as an expert so that's lovely to hear 😊

Expand full comment
Beth Brooke's avatar

Well that’s really nice! Can’t imagine anyone thinking that I know anything much these days. 🤗

Expand full comment
Kathryn Anna Marshall's avatar

we’re so hard on ourselves aren’t we! Love reading your work on here :)

Expand full comment
Angela Joy's avatar

This is so helpful! All you write about here is exactly what makes me feel overwhelmed about trying to submit anything. I’ve saved this for when I come to try. Thank you for sharing all your experiences!

Expand full comment
Angela Joy's avatar

Ps love the bio bit “I’m a better person when I write” 🫶🏽

Expand full comment
Kathryn Anna Marshall's avatar

To be honest I'm beginning to wish that wasn't true! I e just had my pamphlet turned down so am in a proper gloom. Seed sowing tomorrow though which will soothe me 😊

Expand full comment
Bonnie Radcliffe's avatar

So helpful! The behind the scenes work is so rarely shared, but we all have to do it. A great guide.

Expand full comment
Kathryn Anna Marshall's avatar

Aah I'm glad it's useful - the whole thing feels like a maze sometimes

Expand full comment
Bonnie Radcliffe's avatar

A maze that it often feels you are wandering alone! In the wrong footwear, without a torch….

Expand full comment
Kathryn Anna Marshall's avatar

Haha yes in stilettos half the time !

Expand full comment